Thursday, September 17, 2009

Boortz was right

"When Obama becomes our (czar) President any utterance of disapproval with any proposal he floats before the congress will, of course, be racist. It is going to be a fun four years." - Neal Boortz in October 2008


"...Wilson’s shocking disrespect for the office of the president — no Democrat ever shouted “liar” at W. when he was hawking a fake case for war in Iraq — convinced me: Some people just can’t believe a black man is president and will never accept it." - Maureen Dowd (of the New York Times) in September 2009


"I think an overwhelming portion of the intensely demonstrated animosity toward President Barack Obama is based on the fact that he is a black man." - Jimmy Carter in September 2009


"My sense of the teabaggers is more complicated: they are primarily working-class, largely rural and elderly white people. They are freaked by the economy. They are also freaked by the government spending--TARP, the stimulus package etc.--that was necessary to avoid a financial collapse. (I'm not sure Keynes is taught in very many American high schools.) But most of all, they are freaked by an amorphous feeling that they America they imagined they were living in--Sarah Palin's fantasy America--is a different place now, changing for the worse, overrun by furriners of all sorts: Latinos, South Asians, East Asians, homosexuals...to say nothing of liberated, uppity blacks.

In that sense, Barack Obama is the apotheosis of all they fear.
" - Joe Klein (of Time Magazine) in September 2009

Boortz was right.

Conscripting the doctors

Sheldon Richman may have the best health care post I have read yet, even if it is a bit tongue-in-cheek.

Richman gets to the heart of the matter: Changing the way we pay for health care really does nothing to improve on the current system. As Richman says:
Requiring insurance companies to pay for our medical care misses the point. Where do you think insurance companies get their money? From us! What kind of right to health care is it if we end up paying for it anyway? Obama means well, but his plan is a shell game.

Richman goes on to humorously suggest enslaving the doctors, which is really the inevitable end of the progressive ideal.

But it begs a question: How can progressives claim that health care is important enough to be a "right", and at the same time devalue the providers of that "right"?

Wednesday, September 16, 2009

Secession

I am tired and frustrated.

I am tired of arguing with people who believe they have a right to health care, even if it means making indentured servants out of the entire medical profession. Even if means ignoring the U.S. Constitution, which guarantees no right to health care, and in fact prohibits the indentured servitude of any person within the medical profession (see the 14th Amendment).

I am tired of being stigmatized as racist simply because I disagree with these fools. I disagreed with them when the president was white (Bill Clinton), and I disagreed with them when the president was Republican (George Bush's expansion of Medicare), and now I disagree with them when the president is black (Barack Obama). Yet I am somehow racist for not wanting to steal the money properly earned by others in order to fund my own health care needs.

I am tired of the assumption of "all southerners are racists", especially from scalawags like Jimmy Carter. I have lived in the north and the south, and racism is actually less common in the south.

I am tired of my tax dollars supporting welfare states in New York and California. I am tired of my tax dollars supporting an education system that does not work. I am tired of my tax dollars supporting the re-election of liberal/socialist senators and representatives via pork.

I am tired of capitalism being bashed for it's failure, while the role of government in our country's economic collapse is given a pass. While capitalism plays off of man's inherent greed in order to function, where does it say that politicians are any less greedy? Yet we ignore how they have set up laws to protect their own plunder?

I am tired of the Media support for the criminals running our country. They happily bash Republicans, then conveniently overlook when Democrats do the same things, or worse.

I am tired of both political parties fighting over HOW they should run our lives, without anyone stopping to ask WHY they should run our lives. For example, why is prostitution illegal in most parts of our country, yet abortion is legal all over our country? I heard a comedian (I forget his name) put it best: Your womb is free, but the state owns your vagina.

I am tired of the Keynesian fallacy that a small group of people located within a central bank can possibly manipulate our economy positively, when an economy involves literally trillions of different transactions every day. Of course, as we have seen, they cannot do this. Yet no one questions this?

I am tired of reliving the Great Depression. First, our economy goes into recession because of the Keynesian fallacy. Now we have to relive Smoot-Hawley too? Obama's decision to institute tire tariffs against China will only lead to a trade war, which will just make a bad economy worse.

I am tired of the war in Afghanistan. How many wars in Afghanistan have to fail before the world's leaders understand that Afghanistan will NEVER have a useful central government? Entering a war in Afghanistan with the hope of setting up a central government there is like the old joke about second marriages: It's the triumph of hope over experience.

I am tired of the federal government. It provides little while demanding a lot.

The union has outlived it's usefullness. Whenever the rest of you get around to realizing that secession would be better for all of us, let me know. I am ready.

Tuesday, September 15, 2009

The Stupidest Man on the Face of the Earth

What can you say about Ben Bernanke other than the headline above?

On one hand, he says, "The recession is very likely over at this point." On the other hand, he says, unemployment "will be slow to come down...It will come down, but it will take some time." Only a fool could look at rising unemployment rates and think everything is getting better.

If ever there was an argument for disbanding the Federal Reserve and moving to a gold standard, Bernanke is it.

Monday, September 14, 2009

Too big to succeed?

A year after the Lehman Brothers failure, and almost a year after the initial TARP program which was rolled out to save our financial industry by saving those businesses which were "too big to fail", one question remains: What was done to prevent this from happening again in the future?

If a company is "too big to fail", logic dictates that it is simply too big, and needs to be broken up, similar to what happened to AT&T several decades ago. Our government has not only failed to do this, but has instead encouraged the failing businesses to be bought out by other larger businesses (one example being the Merrill Lynch purchase by Bank of America). Instead of breaking up "too big to fail" businesses, we have even bigger "too big to fail" businesses.

One could look at this as a failure of leadership or economic stupidity, but the truth is a far worse thing: These companies are major sources of campaign funding. If they die, politicians will have to find other sources of campaign funding, which won't be nearly as generous. So the politicians happily handed out money they didn't have to these companies to keep them afloat. And now we are stuck with the bill for their largess.

The corruption in the U.S. government has reached astounding levels, where bribes fly back and forth between Wall Street and Washington, and all of it perfectly legal, because the lawmakers have made it legal.

If you think either the Republicans or Democrats are somehow immune to this, just look at the bailouts, which were approved by BOTH parties, and you will see just how deep the money runs in Washington.

It is time to throw out the bums, and I do not mean just the incumbents. I mean the two-party system. If you think you are wasting your vote by voting for a third party, I will tell you that your vote on any Republican or Democrat is just as wasted, because you are voting to maintain Wall Street's hold on power.

Thursday, September 10, 2009

Question of the Day

The big question left unanswered from Obama's speech revolves around this statement from Obama:
Reducing the waste and inefficiency in Medicare and Medicaid will pay for most of this plan.
The question, from Arnold Kling at the Atlantic:
And if we don't pass this plan, does he intend to keep the waste and inefficiency, out of spite?

A Deficit of Ideas

The following quotes are from President Obama's speech last night (transcript from Fox News):
Finally, our health care system is placing an unsustainable burden on taxpayers. When health care costs grow at the rate they have, it puts greater pressure on programs like Medicare and Medicaid.

If we do nothing to slow these skyrocketing costs, we will eventually be spending more on Medicare and Medicaid than every other government program combined.

Put simply, our health care problem is our deficit problem. Nothing else even comes close.
No, our deficit problem is irresponsible politicians spending more than they get in tax revenue. Medicare and Medicaid are just two examples.

Medicaid is a welfare program, period. People who get Medicaid aren't paying for it. Even if they did pay taxes previously, that money was long gone by the time they actually received Medicaid benefits, since our politicians don't let money lie there unspent.

As for Medicare, if you think "I paid into it all my life", you are mistaken. You paid a tax, which the politicians spent on current Medicare expenses, and anything left over was spent on whatever else the politicians decided to spend. But you can be certain it was spent.There was no "Medicare lock box" which held your funds. Can you say "ponzi scheme"?

Even if you believe these programs are necessary, it is economically foolish to give away something for nothing. If grocery stores worked this way, would you be getting steak and lobster every night, or just the food you needed? So why would you expect people with no fiscal responsibility for their own health care to get just what they need when they can get far more? When this happens, the cost of health care rises, not only for taxpayers, but for everyone else who uses health care.

So when Obama proposes a plan which offers more free health care to more people, what do you think will happen to the costs?

For example:
[Insurance companies] will no longer be able to place some arbitrary cap on the amount of coverage you can receive in a given year or in a lifetime.

We will place a limit on how much you can be charged for out-of- pocket expenses, because in the United States of America, no one should go broke because they get sick.

And insurance companies will be required to cover, with no extra charge, routine checkups and preventive care, like mammograms and colonoscopies.

Because there's no reason we shouldn't be catching diseases like breast cancer and colon cancer before they get worse.

That makes sense. It saves money, and it saves lives.

A simple question: Does anyone NEED preventive care in order to live? If they don't have the condition, then the answer is no. Do most people have conditions such as breast cancer or colon cancer? Again, the answer is no. So why should we provide free testing for conditions which will not affect the majority of the American public?

Before you call me heartless, consider this: What happens when you get an incurable cancer? You die. What happens if you DON'T get an incurable cancer? You die. What are we preventing by screening people for cancer? In the end, nothing.

Mind you, I am not insensitive to the horrors of cancer. I saw my mother die from it. But shouldn't we find better ways of treating people AFTER they have cancer? Screening for cancer is NOT 100% effective. Tumors will get missed. Unless you plan to screen everyone everyday, you will miss some. It is inevitable.

The most cost effective approach to cancer is to find a cure for those who have it. THAT will save money and lives.

Speaking of cost effective:
Finally, let me discuss an issue that is a great concern to me, to members of this chamber, and to the public, and that's how we pay for this plan.

Now, Here's what you need to know. First, I will not sign a plan that adds one dime to our deficits, either now or in the future.

I will not sign it if it adds one dime to the deficit now or in the future -- period.

I will not sign it if it adds one dime to the deficit now or in the future. Period. And to prove that I'm serious, there will be a provision in this plan that requires us to come forward with more spending cuts if the savings we promise don't materialize.

How can Obama say he won't sign the bill "if it adds one dime to the deficit" in the future, and in the next breath claim there's a provision that requires spending cuts if savings don't materialize? We know how our legislators treat such provisions: They just override them as needed.

Consider our government's debt ceiling, which Obama & Co. are calling for raising once again, this time above $12 trillion (see this link).

Can Obama guaranty that any costs which raise our deficit will result in spending cuts? As Bill Clinton might have said, it depends on how you define "raising the deficit". Which spending do you consider within our current budget, and within our current deficit? Technically speaking, unless the total cost of this program exceeds our ENTIRE budget, then our politicians can say that NONE of it is increasing our deficit. It's all those other things we are already paying for that are above the current costs.

Very clever Obama. But Joe Wilson was right: You're lying.

Tuesday, September 08, 2009

The Failure of Obamanomics

The failure in President Obama's economic plans is pretty easy to spot. From the Innocent Bystanders website, the following chart shows the original unemployment estimates as presented by President Obama to sell his recovery plan, alongside the actual unemployment numbers since then:

Larry Kudlow has a good analysis of the unemployment problem:
This is a big-versus-small-business issue. Sort of the haves versus the have-nots.

The large companies are gradually recovering as a result of major cost-cutting, inventory reduction, and a lean-and-mean return to profitability and high productivity. So the payroll survey registered a 216,000 job loss, the smallest drop in over a year.

The household survey, however, which picks up small, owner-operated, LLC/S-Corp-type businesses, registered a devastating 392,000 job loss, which follows losses of 155,000 and 374,000 in the prior two months. This is the source of the unemployment-rate jump, as 466,000 newly unemployed were scored in the report.

So while the big companies are getting healthier, the smaller firms are being left in the dust. Unfortunately, small businesses provide most of the new job creation in the United States.

While the big businesses get richer, and the small businesses fail, Obama thinks we need a national discussion on health care? Keep in mind, most small businesses provide little or no health insurance for their employees, so health care is not an issue that will help them. In fact, considering one of the provisions of the health care plan was to place a tax on employers who don't provide health insurance, the current plan could actually hurt small businesses even more if Obama doesn't retract that provision.

Back during Bill Clinton's first presidential run, there was a sign in his campaign headquarters which read: "It's the economy, stupid!" Maybe Hillary has an old copy of that sign she could loan to Obama, because he clearly doesn't understand.

Friday, September 04, 2009

Mr. Rogers gets it right

This speaks for itself:


(special thanks to Jill T. for bringing this to my attention)

Thursday, September 03, 2009

Death Care

From the Daily Telegraph:
In a letter to The Daily Telegraph, a group of experts who care for the terminally ill claim that some patients are being wrongly judged as close to death.

Under NHS guidance introduced across England to help doctors and medical staff deal with dying patients, they can then have fluid and drugs withdrawn and many are put on continuous sedation until they pass away.

But this approach can also mask the signs that their condition is improving, the experts warn.

As a result the scheme is causing a “national crisis” in patient care, the letter states. It has been signed palliative care experts including Professor Peter Millard, Emeritus Professor of Geriatrics, University of London, Dr Peter Hargreaves, a consultant in Palliative Medicine at St Luke’s cancer centre in Guildford, and four others.

“Forecasting death is an inexact science,”they say. Patients are being diagnosed as being close to death “without regard to the fact that the diagnosis could be wrong.

“As a result a national wave of discontent is building up, as family and friends witness the denial of fluids and food to patients."
This is what happens when politics mixes with medicine. Even if Obama and the Obamacare cheerleaders have no intention of making a healthcare system like Britain's NHS, who is to say we won't see this in the U.S. when our government cannot afford to provide wonderful health care for everyone? What happens when our government has to ration health care because the costs have NOT gone down, and in fact have gone up because everyone starts using health care services like a free buffet?

President Obama can laugh off the "death panels" arguments because that is not his intent. But once government controls health care, and it becomes too expensive to provide everything to everyone, what then? By then, it will become another third rail of American politics, and the politicians will be faced with making hidden sacrifices or raising taxes, just as they have had to do in Britain. When faced with a choice of angering all voters, or killing off a few of the already dying voters, which choice is obvious?

Dead voters can't vote against you.

Wednesday, September 02, 2009

No Will for Afghanistan

When a major conservative commentator comes out against a war, much like William F. Buckley came out against Iraq, people take notice. Yesterday, George Will did that on Afghanistan.

Unlike Buckley, Will did not reject involvement completely:
Counterinsurgency theory concerning the time and the ratio of forces required to protect the population indicates that, nationwide, Afghanistan would need hundreds of thousands of coalition troops, perhaps for a decade or more. That is inconceivable.

So, instead, forces should be substantially reduced to serve a comprehensively revised policy: America should do only what can be done from offshore, using intelligence, drones, cruise missiles, airstrikes and small, potent special forces units, concentrating on the porous 1,500-mile border with Pakistan, a nation that actually matters.
The main point Will brings to the table is the simple fact that an "effective central government" has never happened in Afghanistan. Even when the Taliban allegedly were "in charge", they weren't. The warlords were.

Are we prepared to dedicate hundreds of thousands of American troops for decades in order to establish an effective central government in a country which has never had one? Remember, this is not Iraq, which has a history of effective central governments.

Frankly, it doesn't matter if we have world support in our efforts in Afghanistan. Bush was wrong to assume we could do in Afghanistan what we did in Iraq. Obama is wrong to assume the same failed policy.

To be a libertarian

This is the best one paragraph summation of libertarianism I have ever read:
"I share the Founders’ vision of limited government and the ability of people to voluntarily join with others to help their communities and themselves. I don’t agree with the conservatives who want government to play the role of morals policemen, and I don’t agree with the nanny state liberals. I’m a libertarian." - John Stossel

The Government Can!

One of the best music videos I have seen in a long time. And it is so true!

Kudos to Tim Hawkins!

Tuesday, September 01, 2009

See you in September

Some random thoughts on today's news stories:

Gold May Break Out to Record, Grabham Says: Technical Analysis (from Bloomberg.com):
This may include the worst analysis of anything I have read lately. The article begins with:
Gold may advance to a record $1,325 an ounce if it first breaks out of a symmetrical, triangular pattern, a move that may occur in the next one or two weeks, Standard Bank Group Ltd. said, citing trading patterns.

A so-called topside breakout would be indicated by a close at more than $980.85 an ounce, Darran Grabham, the bank’s technical analyst, wrote in a note yesterday. That would signal a short-term bull trend to at least $1,100 an ounce, he said.
Unfortunately, the article reports that Grabham goes on to say:
"...gold may tumble if it declines to less than the support trendline at $935 an ounce, Grabham wrote. “The ensuing sell-off is likely to encounter support around the $906.50 level, before a break lower yields a move to a secondary objective of $890,” he added.

“The minimum target of the triangle is highlighted at $850, with potential for the bear trend to test the corrective low recorded in January,” he wrote.
In summary, Grabham said that gold prices may go up, or gold prices may go down. Brilliant!

Fire Near Los Angeles Spreads in Triple-Digit Heat (from the Wall Street Journal):
Don't we do this every year?

The fact that California likes to protect it's wooded areas from development, keeping them off-limits to zoning, doesn't help. Yes, let us save Bambi, and ignore the fact we are putting thousands of homes and lives at risk. Let's not forget the economic costs of all the annual firefighting operations on an already overextended state budget.

Environmental stupidity at it's finest.

Daily Presidential Tracking Poll (from Rasmussen Reports):
So now Obama's approval rating is down to 45%. At this point, is it safe to add health care to Social Security as "third rails of American politics"?

Go ahead Barack. Keep pushing the health care idea...

WHEN ECONOMISTS ATTACK!
If you don't follow Greg Mankiw or Paul Krugman, you can skip this item. But for those of you who find econo-political debates fascinating...

The latest round between these two economists (in Krugman's case, I use the label "economist" VERY loosely) started Friday when Mankiw posted the following on his blog: "The Least Surprising Correlation of All Time"

Krugman countered with the standard elitist condescension towards the poor, poor, pitiful poor on his blog: "Heredity, environment, justice"

Mankiw counters twice: "And I thought I was being boring" and "Test Scores and Biological Father's Income"
Mankiw is correct in stating that intelligent people, who tend to be wealthier, tend to have more intelligent offspring. The macro data supports his view. Using SAT data broken out by parent's income (as Mankiw does) is a more objective criteria than using college graduation data broken out by parent's income (as Krugman does), since there are fewer external variables to account for in SAT scores. It takes several hours to take the SAT, versus the roughly four years it takes to graduate from college.

Aside from college graduation containing too many variables to be objective, Krugman's example given also has a significant flaw in it: The scores used to determine objective intelligence are 8th grade math scores. This would be fine if all college degrees were based on mathematical ability, but what about other non-math degrees, such as English or History?

With that said, I will admit that I don't reject Krugman's premise entirely. It is certainly possible, and maybe even probable, that children of low income parents who are less intelligent might be less likely to finish college due to financial reasons. But I would think that is because college is more likely to be quite difficult for them, both intellectually and financially. On the other hand, unintelligent wealthy children would only have to face the intellectual hardship of college (even then, only 30% of them graduate, according to the Economic Policy Institute study referenced by Krugman).

The question Krugman fails to ask: Do we REALLY want stupid people graduating from college?

Monday, August 31, 2009

The Rationing of Health Care

I was reading "Confessions of a Health Care Rationer" by Dr. Eric Chevlen, and it occurred to me our entire health care debate is ignoring the inevitable question of health care rationing:
...I have always been opposed to healthcare rationing. But, then, I have always been opposed to aging, too. I have come to recognize the fundamental similarity between the two. They are simply unavoidable evils...The best we can do is to manage them with wisdom and compassion.

It’s a mistake to think of health care as a right. It is not a right; it is a good. Freedom of speech, by contrast, is a right, as is freedom of religious belief. They are privileges that inure to individuals as a consequence of the primordial right, free will. That is why we see them as inalienable. The exercise of these rights does not depend on any action of government, but rather on its inaction. Government may not legitimately interfere with their exercise, but nothing mandates that the government provide us with printing press or chapel.

Health care is different. It is more akin to the other goods which sustain life: food, clothing, and shelter. A well-ordered society exists to protect its members from the unlawful taking of life, and is structured to facilitate its members’ acquisition of these goods.

But health care differs from these other goods: First, health care is not absolutely essential for all people on a daily basis; second, there is an insufficient supply in this world to meet the demand of those who would have it. There is enough food in the world to feed everyone. Hunger and famine are the result of its inadequate distribution, not its absolute dearth. There are enough garments in the world to clothe everyone, and enough roofs to protect all from the rain. Health care, in contrast, is a far scarcer resource. Descartes once remarked that common sense is the most equitably distributed attribute in the world, because we never see anybody who feels he doesn’t have enough. Health care is not like common sense. We often see people who feel they don’t have enough, or at least can’t get enough at a price they’re willing or able to pay.

Until modern times, health care in the United States was distributed as most goods of life are distributed—according to personal wealth. The rich could afford it, and the poor couldn’t. Most economists would exclude this sort of market allocation as a form of rationing by definition. Nonetheless, market allocation is a form of distributing goods within a society, and when there are not enough of those goods to go around, the end-result in the short term is much the same.

Limiting health care’s availability by the criterion of personal wealth rightly offends our sense of the dignity of the individual. Are the lives of the poor not of the same intrinsic value of those of the wealthy? To be fair, it is rare in the United States that poverty alone prevents the uninsured poor from receiving lifesaving intervention in a healthcare crisis. A poor man having a heart attack is not turned away from the emergency room, nor is the poor woman in labor sent away to have her baby at home. (I am not arguing that such enormities never occur, but the fact that such occurrences remain scandalous and newsworthy is a testament to their rarity.) Yet it is equally undeniable that the poor get a lesser share of the preventive care that can maintain health or of the quotidian care for the less dramatic challenges to their health.

First, in answer to his question, "Are the lives of the poor not of the same intrinsic value of those of the wealthy?", my answer is no. Wealth is the mechanism our society uses to determine one's value. Wealth is acquired in accordance with perceived value: Those who offer the most productivity or useful ideas/items tend to have an easier time accumulating wealth than those with little or nothing to offer. We can sit here and point out how our society has some screwed up values when teachers make far less than NFL quarterbacks, but a teacher will only influence a few thousand lives during the course of his/her entire teaching career, whereas a good NFL quarterback may be watched by millions during just one day of his work. Like it or not, a good entertainer DOES have value; however, that is not the source of the problem: The economic reality is we have too many dollars chasing too little value, hence the ever increasing disparity between the wealthy and the poor. But thanks to the recent government bailouts, the politically-connected wealthy have managed to maintain this disparity, instead of facing the deflation which would have brought their wealth down to more reasonable levels. Look at it this way: With deflation, when you have little money like the poor do, the effect on you is actually positive (as prices drop), whereas the wealthy will take a huge hit under deflation as their investments sour and they make less than they did before (assuming their investments don't lose value completely).

Other than that one somewhat misguided assumption by Dr. Chevlen, his article is a must-read. Rationing is inevitable under any third party payer system, as we have seen under our current system as well as other countries where universal health care is present. As Dr. Chevlen goes on to explain:
Rationing must occur, but it need not be admitted. Denying the truth of rationing is more common in government-run health care schemes than private ones, because the government is reluctant to have the people know this ugly fact. Government-run programs, therefore, are more likely to disguise the rationing. This plausibly deniable form of limiting health care is called implicit healthcare rationing, and it assumes many forms. Rationing by termination occurs when patients are discharged from the hospital earlier than is medically optimal. Rationing by dilution occurs when second-best rather than first-best treatment is provided. Rationing by rejection or redirection involves healthcare providers turning away patients whose care will be inadequately reimbursed. This is commonly seen now in the Medicare and Medicaid programs, because those programs reimburse providers at a rate substantially lower than private insurance plans. Perhaps more common than those forms of rationing is rationing by delay, as exemplified by the outrageous amount of time patients in Canada must wait for hip replacement surgery or colonoscopy. The unifying theme in all these forms of implicit rationing is that, without admitting it, they force some patients to forego medical care that they want and are ostensibly entitled to receive.

Private insurance plans sometimes include an element of implicit rationing, but because they are, at heart, contractual agreements between the insurance company and the insured are more likely to ration health care explicitly. The many pages of the healthcare plan describe what is a covered service, which providers will be reimbursed for services, the duration of coverage, the dollar limit, and so on. The advantage of explicit over implicit rationing is obvious: It gives potential customers of the insurance plan information to use when deciding which insurance plan to buy, and gives them clear expectations of services to be delivered. Implicit rationing, by contrast, may have the sweetness of a promise, but is usually succeeded by the bitterness of a promise broken.

...Come, let us speak of unpleasant things. How is health care to be rationed? Who gets the short end of the stick?
While I consider that a classic line, I doubt we will ever have that discussion in any political arena.

Thursday, August 27, 2009

Democratic Rush to Judgment Proves Correct

From the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee's website in March:
Today Rush Limbaugh yet again crossed the line saying: by the time the debate on President Obama's health care plan is over, "it'll be called the Ted Kennedy Memorial Health Care bill.” It is outrageous to demonize a patriotic Senator who has spent his life fighting so that every person has the opportunity to live the American dream.

Tell Republican Party Chairman Michael Steele to denounce Rush Limbaugh once and for all.
Now, from Senator Robert Byrd (quote from Ben Smith at the Politico):
I had hoped and prayed that this day would never come. My heart and soul weeps at the lost of my best friend in the Senate, my beloved friend, Ted Kennedy.

...In his honor and as a tribute to his commitment to his ideals, let us stop the shouting and name calling and have a civilized debate on health care reform which I hope, when legislation has been signed into law, will bear his name for his commitment to insuring the health of every American.
Shame on Senator Byrd! How dare he "demonize a patriotic Senator"!

Tell Democratic Party Chairman Howard Dean to denounce Senator Robert Byrd once and for all.

Heal as I say, not as I heal

Simple solution for the whole health care debate: Whatever health care plan the politicians decide "We the People" need, they have to use too. No exceptions, no special treatment for politicians. Anything we aren't covered for, neither are they. The same goes for all government employees.

To President Obama: If you want single payer so bad, be ready to live with it too. You want a health care system that is "fair" for all Americans, why should you be excluded?

Defining Health Care's Problems

Let's step back from the health care debate for a moment, and define exactly what the problems are (in no particular order):

1. PATIENT COSTS: Even for the middle class, the costs are exorbitant. Between health insurance and deductibles, health care is becoming a burden on Americans of every class. CAUSES: The main cause is the tax deduction for health insurance, which has increased employees covered by health insurance by giving employers a reason to provide it. In turn, it has created a vast third party payer system whereby those covered under health insurance see little expense in utilizing our health care system. However, employees also see their own health insurance costs rising as employers cannot afford to cover their employees health insurance 100%.

2. DOCTOR COSTS: Doctors and hospitals have found their own costs going up. While they can pass along some of these costs to their patients, it is still a burden on our health care system any way you look at it. CAUSES: Medical malpractice has become a gold mine for the legal system (just ask John Edwards who got wealthy from it). Juries are more than delighted to decide for plaintiffs, since the only ones who they see being hurt are the doctors and the insurance companies. Unfortunately, this view is short-sighted, since insurance companies just pass along their costs to ALL doctors, who further pass it along to patients. There is some disagreement about how much of a burden this is on the health care system, but there is no doubt that these costs get passed along.

In addition, because of the hurdles both insurance companies and government programs put in the way of doctors and hospitals receiving payments, staff must be maintained just to deal with third party payers. These staffing costs also get passed along.

3. TREATMENT/DRUG COSTS: Recent years have seen vast improvements in both treatments and drugs, but also a corollary increase in the prices for these. CAUSES: Medical research doesn't grow on trees. For every advance, there are billions of dollars worth of failures. The only way to recoup these losses is to add their cost onto the successes. In addition, FDA requirements add onto the research costs, without necessarily guaranteeing safety. No matter how much research you do, some problems won't become apparent until a drug or treatment is in widespread use. Regardless, the health care consumer is the one who must bear the burden for these advances.

4. THE UNINSURED: This is a gray area. The number frequently quoted is 47 million uninsured, which is true. The problem is who is included in this figure: low income people, illegal immigrants, people between jobs, wealthy people who can afford their own medical costs, young people who could buy health insurance but don't think they need it, people with pre-existing conditions who cannot get health insurance, and poor people who don't realize they are eligible for Medicaid. The only ones here which should be a concern are the low income people, people between jobs, and people with pre-existing conditions who cannot get insurance. The rest either don't want it, shouldn't have it, or are just plain too stupid to live. CAUSES: The only reason this is a problem at all is because of the overall costs of health care. Would anyone worry about the uninsured if health care was available at Wal-mart prices? In addition, the main reason we have uninsured is because the first three items above are causing the health insurance rates to increase.

5. THIRD PARTY PAYER COSTS: Any costs incurred by third party payers, whether they are private insurance or government bureaucrats, will be passed along to the insureds in premium increases. In the case of government bureaucracies, some of these costs can be passed along to taxpayers. CAUSES: In the case of private insurance, their costs are varied, including everything from mail room staff to stock market losses. In the case of government, their costs are relatively fixed, but you still end up paying for government bureaucracies which have no incentive to perform efficiently. Regardless of whether you are covered by private insurance or Medicare, you are paying for an army of people who perform absolutely no function in health care, other than to pay your bill.

Feel free to add any health care problem which I have not covered above.

Wednesday, August 26, 2009

Overlooking the Doctors

Within the health care debate, the people most affected are also the people rarely discussed: doctors.

We talk about poor people who cannot afford health care, while ignoring that Medicaid doesn't fully cover the doctor's expenses of providing that health care.

We talk about "greedy" insurance companies, while ignoring the full staff which every doctor needs to get payment from those insurance companies, because patients don't want to have to deal with their own insurance company. That staff also has to fight government bureaucrats over Medicare claims.

We talk about universal medical records, without a thought as to who will actually be entering the data required to maintain this system.

We talk about providing world class health care to everyone, without considering who will actually be providing this treatment.

Any health care debate that doesn't mention the needs and expenses of the doctors is a pointless discussion.

Consider: How would you feel if the government decided to change the way you do your job, without ever consulting you? And by the way, the government will also be deciding how much money you will earn for what you do. Plus you'll be reporting on everything you do, and if a government bureaucrat doesn't approve of your action, you won't be paid for it. Does that sound like a good plan to you?

Whatever you may think of doctors, they are still the 800 pound gorilla in this debate. If they don't like your plan, they can walk, and there isn't a thing you can do about it. Without the doctors on board, there is not a single health care plan that will work.

This is where the whole "right to health care" argument falls apart. If you assume there is a right to health care, you are also indirectly assuming a right to the labor of another human being, specifically a doctor. Claiming a right to another human being's labor is slavery.

Are you willing to bring back slavery to assure your "right to health care"? Good luck selling the medical community on that one.

UPDATE: After writing this post, I came across a better version of it at Mises.org, written by Dr. Maria Martins. A teaser for your consideration:
Medical care is not a right. Medical care is a service provided by doctors and others to individuals who want to purchase it. A patient presents to the doctor with a request for care. The fact that the patient has a serious condition — even a life threatening one — does not entitle him, as his right, to the services of the doctor. To claim that he does means that doctors and others who provide these services have no rights, or that society can deliberately ignore these rights for the "greater good."

...What is a right? The concept of a right defines freedom to act within the boundaries of the rights of others. It is contradictory to claim that a person has a right to a good or service that requires, for its fulfillment, the violation of someone else's rights. If the exercise of a patient's so-called "right" to healthcare imposes obligations on taxpayers to pay for it and healthcare practitioners to provide it, then it is not a right, but an attempt to enslave one part of the population for the benefit of another part.
Please read the whole article (link here).